By: Greg Mitchell
Back in my scuffling days at the legendary music magazine Crawdaddy in the 1970s, we published a major feature exposing “The Buddy Holly Murder Conspiracy.” It was written by Tom Miller, who went on to write several well-regarded books on his travels in Cuba, Mexico and other points south. Obviously a parody of Watergate/JFK conspiracy probes, it sifted the plane crash evidence and in the end alleged (as I recall) that J. Edgar Hoover and/or Richard Nixon had Holly, Valens and the Big Bopper bumped off in 1959 to kill that no good rock ‘n roll before it led to….the Stooges?
Naturally, a bunch of readers and deejays thought it was for real, leading to some wire service coverage and quite a few chuckles all around.
Now, is it possible, we were on to something? The AP carries a story today (published below) about the Big Bopper’s son getting his body dug up, the fact that a gun owned by Buddy Holly was found on the scene, and a theory that maybe Buddy shot the pilot in a scuffle or something and that led to the tragic crash and “bad news on the doorstep.”
Wild! And no doubt bogus, but a good excuse to run a couple of vintage Buddy and Bopper clips.
Here they are, followed by the AP story. Comments to email@example.com.
Buddy Holly and the Crickets — “Oh Boy.”
The Big Bopper — “Chantilly Lace.”
The son of “the Big Bopper” has hired a forensic anthropologist to try to answer questions about how his father died in the 1959 plane crash that also took the lives of famous rock-and-rollers Buddy Holly and Ritchie Valens.
Jay Richardson, who performs tribute shows as “the Big Bopper Jr.,” hopes an examination of his father’s remains will settle rumors that a gun was fired aboard the plane, and tell whether the Big Bopper might have survived the crash impact and died trying to go for help.
“I’m not looking for any great bombshell, but then again you never know,” Richardson said in a phone interview from his home outside Houston.
J.P. “Big Bopper” Richardson is buried in Beaumont, Tex. After his remains are studied, they will be reburied and a life-size statue will be put up next to the grave.
Jay Richardson never knew his father, who soared to rock fame with his late-’50s hit “Chantilly Lace.” His mother was pregnant with him when his father died.
The music stars were killed on Feb. 3, 1959, when their four-passenger plane crashed after taking off from the Mason City, Iowa, airport — a tragedy memorialized as “the day the music died” in Don McLean’s song “American Pie.”
The group had been traveling by bus on their “Winter Dance Party” tour of the Midwest, but Holly chartered the plane because the bus was cold and prone to breaking down.
Following a concert in Clear Lake, Iowa, Waylon Jennings, then a member of Holly’s band, gave up his seat on the plane to Richardson, who was feeling ill and seeking a shorter trip to the next stop.
An autopsy was performed on the pilot’s body, but not on the others. Bill Bass, founder of the research facility at the University of Tennessee nicknamed the Body Farm, plans to study the remains in March. Bass is an expert in determining identities and causes of death.
In this case, Bass said, his goal is to “document all the fractures and get an idea of how many broken bones and which ones are critical and give . . . as much information as I can about the crash and how it affected his father.”
In its accident report, the Civil Aeronautics Board said pilot error was the cause of the crash. The report didn’t mention a gun belonging to Holly that was found by a farmer two months after the crash.
Newspaper accounts of the gun discovery fueled rumors among fans that the pilot was somehow shot, causing the crash. The owner of the flying service added to the conspiracy theory by insisting his pilot was not at fault, saying the pilot must have been “incapacitated.”
X-rays of the bones should be able to show whether the Bopper was hit by a bullet, because the lead in the bullet would leave debris.
“I don’t expect to find that,” Richardson said. “If these rumors persist, I can tell you Dad wasn’t [shot]. That’s what I hope it comes to.”
Another curious finding at the crash was that Richardson’s body was discovered nearly 40 feet from the wreckage, while the others were found in or near the plane.
Bass said examining the bones could determine whether Richardson could have moved himself from the wreckage or if he was thrown by the force of the crash.
“I don’t know how I would feel to know that my father died some other way than what I believed most of my life,” his son said.