An AI summary describes right-wing coverage of Rep. Jim Jordan as “generally favorable.” Before a reporter puts that phrase in a story, there’s a question to answer: How many outlets reached that judgment independently?
A columnist might call Jordan a fighter. A news story might quote a supporter saying the same thing. If that story runs under several mastheads, the same quote can start to look like a consensus.
Jakub Leps is chief content officer at Newsmatics, a news technology company that indexes published coverage. Its Perspectify platform lets users compare how outlets cover the same story and look up who owns them. To demonstrate Perspectify’s Ask Engine, Leps asked how right-wing outlets covered Rep. Jim Jordan, the incoming House Republican minority leader. The tool summarized the coverage and linked to the articles it used. In this Q&A, Leps explains how he’d check those sources before putting a phrase like “generally favorable” in a story.
E&P: Where would you start if you wanted to compare how different outlets cover the same story?
Jakub Leps: First, I would use Perspectify to search for relevant news on the given topic and set the search filters to include only news articles from neutral sources and public broadcasters. This way, I could find out what relatively unbiased news outlets report about the topic.
Secondly, I would be curious to see what center-left and left-wing publications write about it, what the center-right and right-wing take on the topic is, and finally, I would set the filters to show news articles from pro-government and government propaganda websites to see how they cover the same topic.
E&P: What did you ask the tool about Jim Jordan, and what came back?
Leps: Let’s say I am interested in writing an article about Jim Jordan, the incoming House GOP minority leader, and I want to see how right-wing media cover him. So, in the Ask Engine section of the Perspectify website, I enter a query such as “News about Jim Jordan from right-wing news sources” and get a bullet-point summary of the circumstances surrounding his selection, his plans, and the challenges ahead of him.
The Ask Engine answer allows me to learn, for example, that “Right-wing commentary frames Jordan’s elevation as a response to Republicans’ major midterm losses” or that “The coverage is generally favorable toward Jordan, portraying him as a fighter and an ideological leader, though some reports note concerns that his confrontational style could deepen internal Republican divisions.”
Perspectify’s Ask Engine summarizes how right-wing outlets covered
Rep. Jim Jordan and links to the articles behind its answer.
E&P: Where does the answer come from, and what would you check before publishing it?
Leps: The Ask Engine summary is accompanied by a list of dozens of online news articles from right-wing news sources that served as the basis for the summary.
Our Ask Engine draws solely on news articles in the Newsmatics Index. Our team selects and classifies the outlets that go into that index, and the AI summarizes coverage from that set of publications. So if you’re studying how right-wing outlets cover Jim Jordan, you’re looking at published coverage from outlets we’ve classified that way.
The summary can still miss context, which is why I’d open the articles and check any claim I planned to publish.
E&P: What can the Reports section tell a journalist about who covered a public official?
Leps: In addition to the Search and Ask Engine sections, Perspectify offers a very useful statistics-based section called “Reports,” covering hundreds of American representatives, senators, governors, etc.
To illustrate how this section works, let’s take the example of the Jon Ossoff report. It allows journalists to explore all kinds of statistics related to Jon Ossoff that can be turned into an article or a segment of an article. For example, how many news articles about Ossoff were published during a given period, what types of news outlets covered him the most, what topics were most frequently mentioned in articles about him, in which U.S. states and countries around the world these news outlets were based, or even a Top 10 list of the largest media owners whose news outlets published articles about him.
Perspectify’s Jon Ossoff report tracks daily mentions of the Georgia senator over 30 days, broken down by Perspectify’s outlet classifications.
E&P: What can the Chrome extension tell you when you open an unfamiliar publication?
Leps: The Perspectify Chrome extension is a great tool for learning more about any English-language news outlet. Are they based in the U.S. or in Qatar? Who owns it? A billionaire, a hedge fund, a democratic government, or an authoritarian regime? When was the news outlet founded? Can I access its articles for free, or are they behind a paywall? Is the news outlet neutral, left-wing or right-wing, a public broadcaster, or a government-related propaganda outlet?
E&P: What does the media ownership quiz ask readers to think about?
Leps: The quiz very quickly highlights how people consume news without knowing who owns the media outlets they get their news from. I would use the following analogy: it is as if you were deciding whether to buy a car called Corolla, Model Y or F-Series and had no idea that they were produced by Japan’s Toyota, Elon Musk’s Tesla and Ford, respectively.
E&P: What would you try in the first 15 minutes, and what does it cost?
Leps: I would start with the Ask Engine section and pose several questions on various topics to see how useful it is in providing in-depth summaries supported by concrete online news articles. Then, I would choose one or two U.S. politicians from the Reports section of the website to see how it can serve as a great resource for statistics-based articles. And finally, I would install the Perspectify Chrome extension as a tool that provides me with useful information whenever I visit an online news outlet.
Perspectify is free to use, including Ask Engine, Reports and the Chrome extension.
E&P: Back to Jim Jordan. What would make you drop the story after reading the articles behind the summary?
Leps: I’d drop it if what looked like a pattern came down to a handful of opinion pieces or the same article running under several mastheads. Say I go in thinking right-wing outlets are rallying behind Jordan, and it turns out most of the enthusiasm comes from two columnists. I might have a story about those two columnists. I’d have to give up the bigger claim. The word “generally” has to earn its place in the story.
1 comment on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here
ThePaper
It is amazing to me how so many newsrooms still pursue the golden goose that is technology after what tech has been doing to newsrooms all across the country for about 20 years now. Even a mouse knows to stop eating the cheese.
6 hours ago Report this